Short answer: wear something. Most tights are synthetic, and a cotton layer underneath is more comfortable over a long day and easier to keep fresh. Which layer depends on what bothers you: lines showing, underwear riding up, or thighs rubbing.
The options
Nothing. Some tights have a cotton gusset and are sold as wearable on their own. That works for a few hours. It also means washing the tights after every wear, and a pad has no proper gusset to stick to.
A brief or a thong. The least fabric and the fewest lines. If nothing bothers you, there's no reason to change. The usual complaints: the brief rides up under the tights where you can't fix it, and there's nothing breathable between your thighs.
Boxer briefs. A cotton layer over your hips and upper thighs. It breathes where tights don't, it covers where thighs touch, and the gusset can take a pad. The trade-off is one more layer: the leg edge can show through thin tights and under a tight knit dress.
Shapewear shorts. Smooth under a clingy dress. Usually synthetic and compressive, so warmer.
Do thighs still chafe in tights?
Less than with bare legs, because the tights put fabric between your thighs. What some people get instead is nylon rubbing on nylon, and trapped heat. A cotton layer underneath takes the heat part away. If chafing is your main problem on bare legs, this post covers what to wear under a dress.
Over or under?
Underwear goes under the tights. Some people pull a second pair of shorts over the tights to stop them sliding down. If your tights slide, check their size first. Tights that are too short in the leg are a common reason.
What to look for in the layer underneath
- Cotton against your skin. Tights don't breathe much, so the layer under them should.
- A flat, soft waistband. The tights' waistband sits on top of it. Two hard bands on the same spot dig in.
- A leg that stays down. Once the tights are on, you can't easily pull it back into place. Why underwear rides up, and what helps.
- A flat gusset, if you wear a pad. Tights press everything against your body, which helps, but the pad still needs something to stick to. What to do if a pad keeps moving.
Where ours fit, and where they don't
Our boxer briefs are 95% organic cotton and 5% elastane, made for women, trans and non-binary people, with a pad-friendly gusset in every length.
Under opaque tights with a skirt or a loose dress, the 7cm or 11cm is the one to try: cotton on your skin, and coverage where your thighs touch. Under sheer tights or a tight dress, the leg edge can show. There the 5cm is the better pick, or a brief.
What they don't do: they aren't shapewear. They don't smooth or compress anything.